Tuesday, December 30, 2008

Is the definition of Value equal to a Return On Investment?

Recently I heard a definition of value from an executive of a software company. The definition went something like this: “Added value is the pain that is solved for a given business”. In this case, it is the pain that a software solutions provider can solve for a given business doing an ROI (Return on Investment). Say a customer is having problems tracking and processing orders. A Software sales person comes in and does an ROI to be of "value" to the customer.

The questions begin with, how many orders to you process a day/week/month/year? What is the average order amount and how many orders are canceled or lost because of poor handling?

Say $50 per order is the average, 1000 orders are placed per month and 250 orders are canceled or lost due to poor handling. This ROI formula can be summed up in this question: how much does it cost not to solve a given problem? The ROI could also revolve around different problems.

Now that I have numbers, I can do my math. 1000 orders per month X $50 per order = $50,000 in revenue per month. Now take 250 canceled/lost order X $50 per order = $12,500 in lost revenue per month. This equals to $150,000 in lost revenue a year.

After the ROI analysis, the customer is proposed a solution to solve his or her pain for $150,000 which will give the ROI in 1 year. Great! The sale is done. Hold on a minute. If you are my reader, I hope you are skeptical at this point. Think about it for a minute. The ROI formula = value is ineffective and here is why.

First, I have so far to see any software sales person use the ROI formula successfully. Software sales people do poorly in consultative engagements and business analytics. Any consultant who is good at what he does and who has the customer best interests in mind should know the shortcoming of an ROI analysis. My suggestion is that software sales people and executives buying into simplistic ideas such as a ROI should use them on their own organizations first.

ROI falls flat on its face as a value proposition because the first problem is: how do you measure an ROI? What I have presented above looks really good in theory. Using it practically is a different story. ROI is mostly guess work at its best when attempting to solve problems in poorly managed businesses and not easy to do in well managed businesses. If a given business has a poor system for tracking orders, how will they have anything in place to come up with realistic numbers as outlined above? But let's say a business owner makes a decision to buy a solution if a software sales person manages to persuade him base on ROI analysis.

If the decision is solely made on ROI, then these questions must be answered. Who will be responsible and accountable for measuring the ROI after the sale? Will the software sales person take on this role or someone else? What if the ROI is never realized? How does that speak about the competence for the software sales person?

Most business executives with all kinds of problems in their organizations are afraid to have a realistic look at the unrealized revenue in doing things poorly, never mind doing a realistic ROI. For the software vendor, the billable hour is the cap on unrealized revenue. For the business with poor order tracking, it is a pricing strategy that is lacking. It is a matter of facing real problems, which if pointed out to the executive or software sales person, would either not know what to do or avoid facing them.

Let's say a consultant is faced with a problem to be solved. After asking realistic questions and unable to get strait answers and facing resistance, he or she should know when to back off instead of just making another software sale. Software sales people sell software and have a very poor concept of value selling and consultative engagements.

Granted, on a technical level a ROI analysis may be useful but as a value proposition it has no merit. Value is subjective to the customer and should that involve a ROI analysis it could be part of a value proposition, perhaps only a very small part. Value is created based on perception and then captured by a strategic pricing model. It is multidimensional and simplistic thinkers do poorly with multiple causes and seeing whole pictures.

To actualize a value proposition, one needs to have a good understanding of economics and pricing. Also as an organization, visionary leaders will be crucial in creating and capturing value. For the software vendor, the billable hour stands in the way of creating and capturing value. The most evident of this is in demoralizing and undermining the knowledge worker by the leaders in software vendor companies.

Friday, December 19, 2008

Quote on thinking

I've been traveling in the last while and perhaps a lack of inspiration, so I have not posted for a while. For today it is an inspiring quote from a book I'm reading right now. The book is called The Road Less Traveled & Beyond by Scott Peck. It’s the second time I’m reading it.

"It should go without saying you can't truly communicate well if you don't listen well, and you are unable to listen well unless you are thinking well"

Wednesday, December 3, 2008

Time, a unique resource

Here is a writing from Peter Drucker on time.

Time is also a unique resource. Of the other major resources, money is actually quite plentiful. We long ago should have learned that it is the demand for capital, rather than the supply thereof, which sets the limit to economic growth and activity. People -- the third limiting resources -- one can hire, though one can rarely hire enough good people. But one cannot rent, hire, buy, or otherwise obtain more time.

The supply of time is totally inelastic. No matter how high the demand, the supply will not go up. There is no price for it and no marginal utility curve for it. Moreover, time is totally perishable and cannot be stored. Yesterday's time is gone forever and will never come back. Time is, therefore always in exceedingly short supply.

Time is totally irreplaceable. Within limits we can substitute one resource for another, copper for aluminum, for instance. We can substitute capital for human labor. We can use more knowledge or more brawn. But there is no substitute for time.

Everything requires time. It is the only truly universal condition. All work takes place in time and uses up time. Yet most people take for granted this unique irreplaceable, and necessary resource. Nothing else, perhaps distinguishes effective executives as much as their tender loving care of time.

Man is ill-equipped to manage his time.

Peter Drucker

Thursday, November 20, 2008

Quality Customer Service, Why it matters

In just over a week I will deliver a speech at a local toastmasters club on Quality Customer Service. The title is "Quality Customer Service, Why it matters". If my recording equipment will work well I plan on posting it here on my blog as youtube video.

I'm reading a captivating book on customer service. The book is called "The Only Thing That Matters" by Karl Albrecht. He states that service and quality go together. Quality service he says must be introduce to the whole organization and it is about delivering value to the customer. He points out how so very few businesses get this. The book was written in 1992 and his message still holds true for today.

A quote from the book, "If we're talking about a 'service-driven,' 'customer-focused' organization, we've got to design the operation to work that way. It's more than just a slogan or a training message. It must involve the way we conceive the total product, market it, design the delivery system, program the computer, communicate with the customer, train the employees, and all the rest. And when it comes to the expensive computer systems, if you get it wrong, you stay wrong for a long time."

To adapt a total quality customer service experience is an on going process and takes a lot of thought and risk taking. Individuals of organization who are not willing to take a risk will falter.

Jim Estill recently wrote a blog on risks and made this statement, "Without risks, companies will not be able to thrive."

Saturday, November 15, 2008

Old Dogs Don’t Create New Tricks

I read another inspiring essay by Ron Baker called “Old Dogs Don’t Create New Tricks”

Here are a few quotes and the link to the essay

“If firms, not to mention the profession as a whole, want innovation and dynamism in tandem with attracting the best and brightest talent, they will have to give more authority and responsibilities to their youthful team members. Organizations, like arteries, tend to calcify with age, and young team members––far more prone to adventure and risk-taking––can keep the blood pumping at an extra vigorous pace. No doubt they will make more mistakes and incur more failure, yet risk is where profits come from. The alternative is continued irrelevance of a once proud profession, more and more dependent on regulatory revenue rather than wealth creating innovations that add value to its customers. Ossification is not an option."


“The question for today’s firm leaders is will they allow their young team members the opportunity to create path-breaking services and experiment with new approaches for the benefit of the firm and the profession as a whole, or will they continue to reject too much and adventure too little, remaining satisfied with a settled mediocrity of success and the illusion of security. The posterity of our profession depends on letting the new dogs create new tricks. History proves no one else will."

For the whole essay click here

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

Book Review

Ron Baker has written a fascinating book on pricing.

Rarely is pricing done for the purpose of creating value for the customer. The strategy for pricing put forward in this book is to create and capture value for the customer.

In just about any given business, prices are a result of cost, tracking the margins and other methods that don't take the customer in consideration. It is looking in to the past and not the future. Ron proposes a different strategy for pricing, a strategy to price on propose, as the title of the book suggests. It is value, not cost, that determines price.

What I found the most inspiring in the book is the introduction of a CVO (Chief Value Officer) in to an organization. Ron profiles the world's first CVO in the book.

Ron states that the characteristics of a CVO are to "understand that there is nobility in getting paid what the company is worth. Nothing is more satisfying than customers who believe—and act on the premise—that they get what they pay for. Perhaps the first important characteristic of a successful CVO is high self-esteem; they believe that their company's product and services are worth every penny they charge. They are more concerned with developing a value proposition based on value, not price."

I highly recommend this book. It has already become a reference book for me as I learn more about running a successful business.

I will post another blog with a few quote from an essay I read today from Ron.

Friday, October 31, 2008

My Bookshelf

I recently was recommended this site http://www.shelfari.com/

It is a very useful resource for book lovers. I can post the books I have read, currently reading and books that I want to read. And then also write book reviews, invite friends and see what's on their bookshelf as well. This will motive me to write more book reviews and I also plan to post the book reviews on my blog.

I have my bookshelf on my blog (scroll down...it is on the right) and also on my personal site here http://www.gpeters.ca/bookshelf.html

If you want to see my reviews place your mouse cursor on a given book and you will see a pop up with my review and additional information about the book.

Happy reading!!!